Robert Hassink, Bonn
Regional Innovation Support Systems in South Korea
and Japan Compared
Pages 228 - 245
Since the beginning of the 1990s systems of innovation
have been used as a framework to explain differences in innovativeness
both between firms, industries and economies at a local, regional, national
and supranational level. The main argument behind the discussions around
systems of innovation is that firms are increasingly dependent on institutions
in their direct environment for their innovativeness and thus competitiveness.
In regional innovation systems firms and other organisations are systematically
engaged in interactive learning through an institutional milieu characterised
by embeddedness. On the basis of these systems' governance infrastructure,
a typology can be developed consisting of grassroots systems (with the
highest level of regional embeddedness), integrated systems and dirigiste
systems (with the lowest level of regional embeddedness). This paper
aims at analysing and comparing regional innovation systems in South
Korea and Japan and explaining the differences found between the countries´
systems. Based on empirical research on innovation support agencies
in Kyongbuk-Taegi, South Korea and Hiroshima, Japan, this paper shows
that South Korea is characterised by dirigiste regional innovation support
systems, wheras Japan´s regions have a mixture of relatively well
co-ordinated national and regional agencies with higher levels of local
interaction and "systemness" (integrated systems). The dirigiste
kind of system found in South Korea generates both too homogenous innovation
support agencies, which are not enough focused on specific regional
economic demand, and horizontal policy co-ordnination problems due to
strong vertical dependencies of agencies in the regions to their sponsors
in the central government. The difference in type of systems found in
South Koreas and Japan cannot be explained only by a time lag of development
policies between the two countries, but also by other factors, suich
as the long history of supporting small and medium-sized enterprises
by Japanese prefectures, differences in collective trust and the size
of the countries.
schließen